Kim Kardashian vs. Alicia Keys: Who Wore It Best?

Kim K and Alicia Keys recently wore similar black and white pants

I don't know what it is about these pants that I don't love. Something about the two toned black/white pant thing seems a little off putting to me. My feelings about the clever pants have me in the minority though, because countless celebs swear by the optical illusion pants. Let them tell it, you lose the weight instantly by rocking these trousers. Hmmm who do you think won this round between Kim K and Alicia Keys? Since I don't like the pants, it's hard for me to objective but I want to hear from you. Who wore it best?