Naomi Campbell and Alicia Keys square off in identical gown. Who woreit best?

I love a good style show-down and boy do I have a fun one for you. Singer Alicia Keys & Supermodel Naomi Campbell both wore this mermaid hemmed Azzedine Alaia gown recently at separate events. Alicia rocked hers burgundy number and the Superbowl and Naomi wore her white-hot gown to the premiere of new show "The Face" last night. It's a close call but I love this look on Alicia, anytime you wear a fishtail gown you MUST have curves to fill it out. This outfit falls a little flat on the newly minted reality star. Now I want to hear your thoughts. Between Naomi and Alicia, who rocked it best?